Moment in Peking by Lin Yu Tang

HomeForumBooksMoment in Peking by Lin Yu Tang


Halaman 1 2 3 sesudah
#1
eeyore 5 Juni 2009 jam 5:34am  

Mungkin bakalan cuap2 sendiri, tp klu ada yg mao nimbrung silahkan ^__^

Belon selesai baca, tp sudah di part ke 2 :D bacanya lama soalnya banyak distraction (i.e. crocheting, V6 :p) Makin lama makin seru dan makin banyak bedanya sama filmnya.

Menurut temen yg dari China, emg Lin Yu Tang ini orang nya detail, sampe gue yg ce aja baca nya cape (emg malas sih baca deskripsi kadang2) dia cerita details banget soal ruangan, mejanya, curtain nya, soal perhiasan, soal baju, soal taman, semuanya details. Selain dari itu daku suka sama ceritanya. O iya karakter nya jauh lebih banyak, tp untung di halaman depan ada diagram siapa anak sapa... klu ga mabok jg.. hehehehehe.. da gitu sebagian namanya mandarin sebagian di terjemahin jadi english. Kayak Silverscreen, Dimfragrance, Littlejoy, Coldfragance... hehehehehe..

Spoiler buku, bahaya (khususnya yg mo baca)

Perbedaan paling menonjol buat aku dibandingin sama film adalah Sunya cinta sama Mulan waktu menikah, tidak ada Li Hua di sini. Bahkan sampai Mulan anak dua, Sunya masih cinta sama dia. Daku jadi tambah suka sama Sunya. Jg tragedi Mulan gantiin Mochow untuk kawin sama Sunya tidak ada tuhhh.... Mochow emg suka sama Lifu dari awal, well Mulan jg suka sama Lifu sih, tp krn pas dia sadar dia cinta sama Lifu, dia sudah di jodohin sama Sunya.

Daku suka banget sama karakter Mulan bukan krn dia pintar baik cantik dan kaya, tapi karena dia content sama keadaan tapi tidak berarti dia menderita. Dia content kawin sama Sunya yang tidak punya ambisi, tapi dia tetap bisa menikmati kehidupan perkawinan nya sebatas yg ditawarkan. Belon kelar sih bacanya soalnya si Mulan ada ide2 aneh kadang, masak dia mo cariin Sunya istri kedua... duh! orang dulu emg aneh, sampe kata pengarangnya, mungkin Mulan di anggap immoral buat jaman kita skrg, tp dia begitu krn dia melihat banyak keadaan dijaman nya ada istri kedua lebih baik. heheheheheheee.. I'm not arguing deh.

nanti klu ada lagi di komen lagi disini :D

banyak2 quote aku suka nanti di cari dulu halamannya :D

#2 avatar
Tasha 5 Juni 2009 jam 8:19am  

olala nama pake setengah2, kenapa gak semua mandarin aje ye.....
gue juga males baca deskripsi, biasa baca kilat doang :D

#3
eeyore 5 Juni 2009 jam 10:11am  

mao versi chinese nie? ada tuh temen gue, word doc hehehehehe..

#4
Azalae 5 Juni 2009 jam 1:47pm  

kalo ga salah ada serinya.

#5 avatar
Tasha 5 Juni 2009 jam 4:46pm  

weleh bacaan berat kalo versi chinese.....
tp boleh juga tin, emailin gue dong, thanks.....

bos, iya ada serinya yg maen vicky zhou

#6
Nest_or 6 Juni 2009 jam 4:59am  

permisiiii... bukunya english version ya?

#7
eeyore 9 Juni 2009 jam 6:29am  

sorrryyyy baru reply. iya bahasa inggris yg daku baca. tinggal 1/3 lagi abis :D seerruuuu...

some my fave paragraphs so far...

Kutip:
Page 301]
Mr. Yao realized that he was ahead of his times, that it woul be unfair to let his daughters stand alone, trying to catch husbands, while the other girls of their generation had their parents' planning, forethoughts, and helos in finding the best young men of their age. Time was important, for the best young men were usually spoken for ahead. In other words, "free marriage" was to him a Utopian idea to toy with. Why, a modest girl would rather die unmarried than use her charms to hunt and capture a husband for herself! How cheap and undignified it appeared then, and how cheap and undignified it actually become as he saw it later!

In the present generation after Mulan, some of the best girls remain unmarried because times have changed. The best girls are too decent to go out hunting husbands for themselves, and their parents have lost the power to arrange matches with parents of desirable young men

Kutip:
Page 324
In the old China, one's motive for being good lay in the desire to live worthily of one's family and preserve it name and fortune. Only so we can explain the strong moral tradition, the emphasis on conduct, and the platitudes and interminable moralizing that permeated literature and history from the classics down, and followed a person even to his coffin.
more coming later...

annie, nanti gue email yah, minta dulu sama dia :D

#8 avatar
Tasha 9 Juni 2009 jam 9:08am  

sip, tin.......
baca kutipan elo kayaknya nih bakal cape baca ni buku, padet bener.....

#9
eeyore 9 Juni 2009 jam 9:22am  

emang. hahahahhaa.. makanya ga kebayang gue hrs re-type semua.. bisa RSI gue abis klar satu buku hihihihii.. jadi gue masih coba cara lain sabar yah nie. temen gue aja itu word doc chinese da 500+ halaman dan blon kelar jg... lol...

#10
Azalae 9 Juni 2009 jam 12:58pm  

actually, interesting details. detil kaya gini gua malah suka. :yes:

#11 avatar
Tasha 9 Juni 2009 jam 3:02pm  

hihi jadi bos yg mo ngetikin :p

buset 500+ baca tulisan chinese begitu bisa kriting juga, palingan ntar gue baca skip2 or skimming yg mana susah buat tulisan chinese^^

#12
eeyore 10 Juni 2009 jam 8:54am  

aahh lagi sedih gue..


anak ce Mulan yg paling besar mati gara2 ikut demo revolusi, baru umur 15 thn... :cry:

#13 avatar
Tasha 10 Juni 2009 jam 8:59am  

Tin, yg dipilem itu abis di bab berapa?
gue kemaren skimming ebooknya....
trus yg si Shun Ya selingkuh itu di bab berapa?

#14
eeyore 10 Juni 2009 jam 9:45am  

film kecampur2, ga ikutin timeline buku bener2. paling akhir kayaknya sebab gue sampe skrg blon ketemu sama Li Hua. klu menurut temen gue juga kayaknya ga sampe selingkuh, dunno deh.. Mulan kacian deh abis kena tragedi... :hug:

#15 avatar
Tasha 10 Juni 2009 jam 1:38pm  

gue kemaren baca yg bagian lo spoiler tag, tp cuma sekilas2, soalnya pas lagi cari2 si li hua itu, ntaran gue skimming2 lagi...

#16
eeyore 11 Juni 2009 jam 8:29am  

i know now why sunya have a mistress, still wrong of him, but Mulan did something... blon ketemu li hua sih, tp gue da curiga... dan temen gue jg blg gitu... hiks. nothing perfect.

#17 avatar
Tasha 11 Juni 2009 jam 8:52am  

weleh baca novelnya kok kayaknya menyesakkan dada.........
gue tunggu komen lo aja tin, siap2...

#18
yinyeksin 12 Juni 2009 jam 12:17am  

tin, kalo re-type bagi2 ya :p lho, mang yang doc chinesenya sampe segitu banyak ya? total berapa bab sih?

#19
eeyore 12 Juni 2009 jam 5:42am  

good news, gue dpt buku nya... I bought it hehehehheee.... ebay! tp blon sampe, mungkin 1-2 mg? dari US soalnya. klu buku ada ditangan kan gampang gue re-type jg ga dikejar2 sama library hehehehehhehee... btw, rada challenging jg re-type sebab luar biasa detail dan gue ga gitu suka baca soal politik jadi yah... klu nanti ada di skip gpp kali yah? hahahahahahaha.. namanya saduran bukan ketik ulang yah :D

btw, daku sudah ketemu li hua... mulan bener2 aneh, antara sangat modern dan sangat kuno. I got a little over 100 pages to go... haiizzz... bakal mixed feeling reviewnya sama karakter mulan. susah jadi reviewer yg objective yah... haiiizzz...

#20 avatar
Tasha 12 Juni 2009 jam 9:49am  

heheehe lo kepengaruh karakter mulan yg di film gak?
ternyata malah li hua munculnya mendekati akhir ya.....
tuh film bener2 beda, hmmm.....

Halaman 1 2 3 sesudah