Post-32525

Post 55 dari 92 dalam Fire and Rain (QSSYMM)

HomeForumBooksFire and Rain (QSSYMM)Post-32525

#55 avatar
hey_sephia 12 Oktober 2006 jam 1:43pm  

ada yg agak janggal.

<< kritikus mode on >>

Fang Yu kan jadi katolik sejati banget gitu, biasanya kalo orang katolik denger orang bunuh diri itu ngga trus ngomong gini:

Fang Yu put her arm around me and patted my shoulders. ‘Don’t cry – life and death is all a matter of fate.’

trus.. she also said:
[i have to put in spoiler tag, so that i don't reveal who she was talking about.]

‘The two sides of living – life and death – can you prove which side is the more fortunate? Ru Ping has freed herself from worldly concerns; she left pain behind for the living to deal with. We all look at death as being some tragic event, but that’s only our point of view – those of us who’re still alive. To those who are dead, the moment they die they have no more feelings of happiness or sadness, pain or desire.’

hmm.. i guess probably u'd have to be a catholic to understand what i meant? :? males jelasin jg.. however this is more like a buddhist principles, i think. mgkn bisa bilang si fy cuma mau menghibur yiping, tapi ini kan melanggar apa yg dia percayai? dan si fang yu ini model orang yg speak her mind, apa adanya. at least kalo dia emg bener2 katolik, dia bakal sedikit menyalahkan orang yang bunuh diri. ga ada good enough reason for anyone to kill her self, that kind of things. and fate - fate is not part of catholic teachings too, i think.

also.. another thing..
about shu huan..

bukannya dia pernah tinggalin yiping once, and she almost died because she went crazy, soaked in rain etc. what made him think she wouldn't do it again this time? ok he can't bear the thought that he 'killed' ru ping, but.. can he bear the thought that he 'killed' two sisters? logikanya di mana mas??? i thought you were smart. :no: